A 1.6% Real Estate Agent Commission Can Cost More Than a 2.2% One

A seller who rings around will usually end up with three agents and three percentages. The percentage is the number that gets compared, and it says the least about what the sale will cost. The bill is decided by the written sales authority each agent asks the seller to sign, because that document fixes the commission, the marketing spend, the term, and what is owed if the home does not sell.

The position here is simple. Price each agent on the authority at three outcomes (the home sells at the estimate, sells higher, or does not sell) rather than on the headline rate. Commission and expenses are negotiable, and in Victoria the agent must say so before the seller signs. This guide sets out a three-quote sum on one hypothetical home, what regulators in five states say, and the questions to put in writing. It is general information, not legal or financial advice.

The headline rate is the smallest thing to compare

Published averages do not settle what a rate should be. One comparison guide, dated 11 March 2026, puts the national average at 2.23%, Victoria at 2.04%, New South Wales at 2.02% and South Australia at 2.01%, the lowest of the state figures it lists. A second guide gives Victoria as 1.80%, stated to include GST, with individual rates running from 1.06% to 3.29%. Two averages for one state, where one is stated GST-inclusive and the other does not say, make any average a rough anchor only. None of the five regulator pages read for this guide publishes a typical rate, and Queensland’s says no limit is set on commission.

GST needs its own question. Queensland requires the rate to include GST and the appointment to say so. Elsewhere, ask each agent whether the quoted figure includes it. Every figure in the worked example below does.

Rates also come in shapes: a flat percentage on the whole price, a tiered scale with a higher rate on the part above a threshold, or a flat dollar fee. Asking exactly how a professional is paid is the same habit that applies when weighing a mortgage broker against a bank.

The sales authority is the document being negotiated

A sales authority is the written agreement that appoints the agent. It fixes the commission, the expenses the seller may be asked to pay, the agent’s estimate of the sale price, the term, and what is owed if the home does not sell. The regulator pages for Victoria and Western Australia treat it as legally binding once signed, so the reading belongs before the signing.

In Victoria the agent must tell the seller, before signing, that commission and expenses are negotiable, and a percentage must come with a dollar example. An agent there also cannot claim commission without a compliant written authority and a signed copy. In Western Australia commission is not fixed: it can be a set fee, a percentage or both, and it must sit in the written authority.

The practical step is to ask each agent for the unsigned authority ahead of the appointment and read it at home. New South Wales offers a one business day cooling-off period (to 5pm the next business day), but a seller elsewhere should not assume one exists. The contract of sale is a separate document that follows, and deciding early between a conveyancer and a solicitor keeps that step from being rushed.

Three quotes, one house

Take a hypothetical home that the seller expects to sell for $900,000, and three hypothetical written quotes. All figures include GST. Marketing is whatever the authority lists. The three marketing amounts sit at or below the 0.5% to 1% of value that one comparison guide describes as an older rule of thumb, so they are a rough guide only.

Quote Rate Marketing Commission at $900,000 Total at $900,000 Total at $950,000 Total if it does not sell
A 1.6% $9,000 $14,400 $23,400 $24,200 $9,000
B 1.9% $6,000 $17,100 $23,100 $24,050 $6,000
C 2.2% $3,000 $19,800 $22,800 $23,900 $3,000

Hypothetical example, not a quote or a typical rate. Commission and marketing both include GST.

Quote A carries the lowest rate and is the dearest of the three at $900,000 and again at $950,000. The rate gap between A and C is 0.6 of a point, which is $5,400 on $900,000. The marketing gap is $6,000, and it more than cancels the saving. The rule for any pair is to divide the marketing gap by the rate gap, which gives the break-even price. Here that is $6,000 divided by 0.006, or $1,000,000. At $1,000,000 all three quotes cost $25,000. Above that price, A is the cheapest. The title of this guide therefore holds below $1 million and stops holding there.

Each 0.1 of a percentage point is $900 on this home, and each $1,000 of marketing is about 0.11 of a point, which turns any rate-versus-marketing trade into one dollar figure.

The last column matters as much as the others. If the home does not sell and the authority makes the marketing payable, A leaves $9,000 owing and C leaves $3,000. If the seller negotiates a no sale, no fee clause, that column becomes $0 for whichever quote carries it. A tiered scale changes the arithmetic, so the same three outcomes should be run on it. Competition between agents is real, and three quotes are cheap insurance, provided the written terms sit beside the rates.

What the marketing line pays for

Marketing in a listing commonly covers portal advertising, photography and presentation, styling and, for an auction, the auctioneer. One comparison guide puts published auctioneer prices in Sydney, Melbourne and Adelaide at $700 to $1,100. Portal prices vary by suburb, so a marketing quote compares properly only with another from the same suburb.

A bright staged living room with a grey sofa, a timber coffee table with native flowers and a camera on a tripod set up for listing photography

Ask for every item, with its dollar amount, in the authority. Then ask whether the agent receives a rebate or a discount on any of it. Victoria requires a rebate statement and bars the agent from keeping a rebate. New South Wales requires the agreement to state any commissions or discounts the agent receives on advertising and similar costs. Western Australia bars an agent from charging more than the seller authorised in writing, or more than the agent paid. It is the same habit that makes reading a removalist quote useful: a list of items can be compared, while a lump sum cannot.

What happens if the home does not sell

Commission is usually paid on a sale. Marketing is a different matter, and the headline rates skip it. Consumer Protection WA says marketing and advertising costs are generally payable even if the property does not sell, unless the authority has a no sale, no fee arrangement. Queensland requires the agreement to state whether commission is owed if the sale does not go ahead. Consumer Affairs Victoria treats no sale, no fee as an arrangement the seller can ask for, meaning no commission or outgoings unless the agent sells.

Some comparison guides present no sale, no fee as built into the commission model. The regulator pages read here describe it as a separate clause, so a seller who assumes it is included may find the marketing bill arrives anyway. There is a fair point on the other side: an agent who carries that risk may reasonably price the rate differently. The way to judge the trade is the same three-outcome sum.

How long the authority runs, state by state

The term and the exclusive period decide when a seller can walk away and when an agent can still claim commission. Each rule below carries conditions, so read the qualifiers.

State Negotiable and disclosure Expenses and estimate Term and exclusive period
Victoria Agent must say before signing that commission and expenses are negotiable Marketing agreed in the authority is still payable; estimate is one figure or a range of up to 10% Sole or exclusive authority ends 30 days after an auction or 60 days after a private sale authority is signed, unless otherwise agreed; an exclusive agency can claim commission even if the seller sells without its help
New South Wales Commission, fees and expenses negotiable; ask each agent for a printed list Agreement must state amounts or estimates, including any commissions or discounts the agent receives; estimate needs evidence, range of no more than 10% Open ended or fixed term, no set minimum or maximum; ends by written notice; one business day cooling-off
Queensland No limit on commission; rate must include GST and be in writing at appointment Agreement lists fees, charges, advertising and marketing costs, and whether commission is owed if the sale does not go ahead; if the agent suggests an asking price, the Queensland page requires a comparative market analysis of at least 3 comparable sales Exclusive or sole agency up to 90 days, with extra notice rules over 60 days; an exclusive agency is paid regardless of who sells
Western Australia Commission not fixed; set fee, percentage or both, in the written authority Marketing generally payable even if the property does not sell, unless no sale, no fee applies; agent must not charge more than authorised or than paid Exclusive period set in the authority (the page states no cap); most contracts give the agent the fee if the seller sells privately or through another agent in that period, possibly for a set period afterwards
South Australia Fees and terms negotiable; changes in writing signed by both Fees and charges must be listed; estimate is a single dollar figure, no ranges Up to 90 days; sole agency is the most common, and the agent can still earn commission if the seller sells the house alone

Each row paraphrases the regulator’s page as last updated: Consumer Affairs Victoria (13 October 2023 and 5 May 2021), NSW Government (8 July 2026), Queensland Government (20 October 2020 and 19 July 2024), Consumer Protection WA (25 June 2026), SA.GOV.AU (9 June 2026). Rules change, so check the current page.

Readers in Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory should read their own regulator’s page before signing, as this guide makes no claim about those jurisdictions. Victorian sellers should also note that, per Consumer Affairs Victoria (updated 22 October 2026), the Property Price Statement replaced the Statement of Information from 1 October 2026, and from 16 October 2026 the reserve for auctions and fixed-date sales must be published 7 days ahead.

Is the higher-rate agent ever worth it?

Take a second hypothetical: a 2.5% agent against a 2.0% agent on a $900,000 home. At the same price the 2.5% agent costs $4,500 more. Because that agent also takes a share of any uplift, the sale price would need to be about $4,615 higher, roughly 0.5%, for the seller to finish level (marketing set aside).

A higher rate can reflect more work or a better result, and that is a fair point. The sources opened for this guide do not show whether any agent achieves it, so no side is taken on agent value. The useful request is evidence: Victoria requires the estimate to be reasonable and based on comparable sales, and New South Wales requires evidence behind it.

Ten questions to put to each agent in writing

Read the answers the way a booking contract is read when hiring a wedding DJ or a live band: what does the paper commit each side to?

  1. What is the rate, and does it include GST?
  2. Is the rate flat or tiered, and at what thresholds?
  3. What is every marketing item, with its dollar amount, and does the agent receive a rebate or discount on any of them?
  4. Who is paid what if the home does not sell?
  5. Is no sale, no fee on offer, and how does the price change if it is?
  6. How long is the term, and what applies if the home sells without the agent during it, or afterwards?
  7. What is the estimate, and which comparable sales sit behind it?
  8. How can the authority be ended early?
  9. Who handles the contract of sale?
  10. Does this quote hold if the home sells at the estimate, sells higher, or does not sell?

What to settle before you sign

Settle the written authority before the rate. Ask for it unsigned, price it at the three outcomes, and remember that commission and expenses are negotiable. Marketing is generally payable even if the home does not sell, unless the authority says no sale, no fee. Below the break-even a lower rate with heavier marketing can be the dearest quote, and above it the order reverses, so run the sum on the price the home is expected to reach. Read the regulator page for the relevant state, and have a conveyancer or solicitor look over the contract of sale.


Sources: Selling property with or without an agent, Consumer Affairs Victoria (https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/housing/buying-and-selling-property/selling-property/selling-property-with-or-without-an-agent); Authorities, rebates and commission, Consumer Affairs Victoria (https://consumer.vic.gov.au/licensing-and-registration/estate-agents/running-your-business/authorities-commissions-and-contracts/authorities-rebates-and-commission); Agency agreements for the sale of property in NSW, NSW Government (https://www.nsw.gov.au/housing-and-construction/buying-and-selling-property/selling-a-property/agency-agreements); Charging commission for selling and letting in the property industry, Queensland Government (https://www.qld.gov.au/law/laws-regulated-industries-and-accountability/queensland-laws-and-regulations/regulated-industries-and-licensing/regulated-industries-licensing-and-legislation/property-industry-regulation/legal-requirements-for-the-property-industry/charging-commission-for-selling-and-letting-in-the-property-industry); Appointing a real estate sales agent, Queensland Government (https://www.qld.gov.au/housing/buying-owning-home/selling-a-home/before-you-put-your-home-on-the-market/appointing-a-real-estate-sales-agent); Selling property, Consumer Protection WA (https://consumerprotection.wa.gov.au/selling-property-0); Engaging a real estate agent, SA.GOV.AU (https://www.sa.gov.au/topics/housing-and-property/buying-building-selling/selling-a-property/engaging-professionals); New changes to property sales and underquoting laws, Consumer Affairs Victoria (https://www.consumer.vic.gov.au/licensing-and-registration/estate-agents/new-changes-to-property-sales-and-underquoting-laws); Real Estate Agent Commission: Rates and How to Calculate, LocalAgentFinder (https://www.localagentfinder.com.au/blog/real-estate-agent-commission); Real estate agent fees and commissions in Victoria, OpenAgent (https://www.openagent.com.au/real-estate-agent-fees/vic)

Comments

  • No comments yet.
  • Add a comment